How to Deny an Employee’s Promotion Request (Without Hurting Retention)

Turning down a promotion request is one of the harder parts of managing people. When handled poorly, it can lead to disengagement, resentment, or even a resignation. When done well, it can actually strengthen trust and keep employees motivated. For Ontario employers, how you deny an employee promotion request matters just as much as the decision itself. Keep reading to find out what a good denial process looks like and best practices from a recruiter. 

How You React to a Promotion Request is Important

Being passed over for a promotion, while a normal part of employment, runs the risk of draining morale. Employees tie career growth to job satisfaction, and a rejection doesn’t just get in the way of advancement — it feels personal, and hurts confidence. 

That’s why denying employee promotion requests requires care. Employers who reject promotion requests carelessly demotivate and prompt employees’ to look elsewhere for career opportunities. A thoughtful response helps employees stay engaged and reassures them that their effort is noticed, even if the answer is “not right now.”

Looking for Expert Recruitment Help? — The Best Talent is Waiting for You

How to Deny a Promotion Request From an Employee (Without Hurting Retention)

Consider Them (Even if You Don’t Think They’re a Good Fit)

Every promotion request deserves real attention (and yes, employees can tell when you’re glossing over them, even if you try to be discreet). 

Taking time to listen shows respect and builds trust. If we were to break this topic into dos and don’ts, an immediate rejection is a big “DO NOT DO” for us. It’s dismissive and discouraging.

So genuinely consider them, even if you believe they aren’t ready. Don’t pretend to consider them, truly consider them. Employees in junior or behind-the-scenes roles often contribute more than managers realize. A proper discussion may highlight skills or potential that wasn’t obvious.

Promotion requests often come in the form of a 1-on-1 meeting, during which you should give them the space to explain their interests, goals, and why they’re the right choice.

Give the Employee a Clean Slate

During the consideration phase, it’s important to give the employee a completely clean slate. Focus on where they are today, not where they struggled in the past. Previous mistakes or early performance issues should not outweigh recent growth and contributions.

We’ve seen some employers bring up old mistakes as a reason for rejection. Often, it’s just a scapegoat. If a past mistake is the only reason you have for rejection, it isn’t good reasoning. You aren’t being objective, and using past mistakes as an excuse is not going to go unnoticed by the employee.

Instead, approach the decision with clear, objective criteria tied to the role’s requirements. Let the employee know you are assessing their current skills, strengths, and contributions. This helps them feel fairly evaluated rather than judged on old issues.

Book a 1-on-1 Meeting to Discuss the Promotion Request

Where many employers go wrong is in how the message is delivered. Denying a promotion through email or a rushed hallway conversation sends the wrong signal. 

It brings us back to that “dismissive” issue we talked about before. Your employee is invested in this conversation, and you should be mirroring that investment back to them. They deserve more than an email.

This is a sensitive discussion that necessitates a private, 1-on-1 meeting. Internal candidates have invested time and loyalty in your organization. Taking the time to speak face-to-face shows professionalism and respect, even when the outcome isn’t what they hoped for. This simple approach can lessen the blow considerably. 

Provide Honest Reasoning

Where most employers go wrong: they avoid being straightforward and direct about the rejection and try to sugarcoat. 

Let’s just be direct here, sugarcoating doesn’t help anyone, neither you or the employee. 

You may think you’re helping, but trust me, vague answers are more frustrating than a direct explanation. Be honest about why the employee isn’t ready for the role, while keeping the tone respectful, professional, and polite.

Give Advice for Improvement

A promotion denial should not be the end of the conversation. Share specific, actionable steps the employee can take to strengthen their chances in the future.

This might include developing leadership skills, gaining experience with certain projects, or improving communication or technical abilities. Clear guidance turns disappointment into direction and shows that growth is still possible within your organization.

As an employer, it’s your responsibility to give your employees access to upskilling/mentorship opportunities, especially if the skill development they need isn’t available in their current role.

In the example response below, we use the example of an employee in management that excels in people management but lacks skills in finance. This is because they are in a completely people-focused role. 

This is an example of an employee who hasn’t had the opportunity to grow the skills needed for the promotion due to limits in their job responsibilities. In this case, providing upskilling/mentorship opportunities makes sense. 

Encourage Them to Keep Asking for Promotions

Reassure the employee that the request is not a problem. Let them know you welcome future promotion discussions and that their interest in growing is valued.

Encouragement goes a long way in maintaining motivation. When employees feel supported, they’re more likely to stay engaged, work toward clear goals, and continue building their career with your company instead of looking elsewhere.

The Perfect Response When Denying an Employee's Promotion Request

Keeping in mind everything we’ve discussed so far, such as direct feedback and advice for improvement, here’s an example of what your response should sound like when denying a promotion request:

The Scenario: The employee who made the request is in a management role, focused almost entirely on people management. However, the promotion she’s looking for is for a role which requires not just people management, but also financial management. Their current role includes very limited financial responsibilities, which is the main reason why she has been rejected for the promotion. 

The Ideal Response:  “Firstly, I want to say how glad I am that you’re eager to move up in the organization. That attitude is exactly what we’re looking for in our workforce. 

Unfortunately, after considering your request, I don’t think I can offer you a promotion at this time. The position you’re aiming for requires rigorous cashflow management and financial forecasting, which you have yet to do consistently in your current role. 

For this role, I need to confidently depend on your ability to manage our finances and budget without any oversight. I don’t feel confident depending on you for these types of responsibilities just yet. 

You have shown substantial improvements in your ability to manage and lead a team. Please know that these improvements have not gone unnoticed. If you are interested, I am happy to discuss upskilling opportunities with you to help improve whatever skills you’re missing. 

I am looking forward to discussing opportunities like this with you in the future.”